PUBLISHED OPINIONS
December 2002
Disclaimer: Formatting and page numbers of the electronic version of First Circuit opinions may not exactly match the original hard copy.
To download a file, right click on the link (case number) and select "Save Target As" for Internet Explorer or "Save Link As" for Netscape Navigator.
| 1999CA2420 |
IVAN L. HAND, JR. VS GWENDOLYN ROBINSON HAND |
| 1999CA2420
(rehearing) |
IVAN L. HAND, JR. VS GWENDOLYN ROBINSON HAND |
| 2000CA0465 |
J. JUDE QUEBEDEAUX AND WENDY QUEBEDEAUX VS THE DOW CHEMICAL COMPANY, JOHN DANDRIDGE, RELIANCE INSURANCE COMPANY AND DORINCO REINSURANCE COMPANY |
| 2001CA0205
|
EL CHICO RESTAURANTS OF LOUISIANA, INC. VS LOUISIANA GAMING CONTROL BOARD CONSOLIDATED WITH EL CHICO RESTAURANTS OF LOUISIANA, INC. VS LOUISIANA GAMING CONTROL BOARD |
| 2001CA0205
(rehearing) |
EL CHICO RESTAURANTS OF LOUISIANA, INC. VS LOUISIANA GAMING CONTROL BOARD |
| 2001CA0506 |
IMPERIAL TRADING CO., INC. VS MICHAEL J. UTER, JACK G. MENZIE, TOBACCO MART AND D/B/A TOBACCO MART, TOBACCO MART OF VICKSBURG, TOBACCO MART OF BOOKHAVEN, TOBACCO MART OF VIDALIA, TOBACCO MART OF GREENVILLE, TOBACCO MART OF MCCOMB, TOBACCO MART OF BATTLEFIELD, ET AL. |
| 2001CA1014 |
RUSSELL BOLEWARE VS CITY OF BOGALUSA |
| 2001CA1014
(rehearing) |
RUSSELL BOLEWARE VS CITY OF BOGALUSA
|
| 2001CA1085 |
OLIVER BETHLEY VS KELLER CONCRETE, MAPP CONSTRUCTION AND ST. PAUL FIRE AND MARINE INSURANCE COMPANY |
| 2001CA1187 |
SALVADOR R.
DUZON, CAROLYN R. DUZON, ON BEHALF OF THE COMMUNITY OF ACQUETS AND GAINS,
INDIVIDUALLY AND ON BEHALF OF THE MINOR CHILDREN, SALVADOR DUZON, JR. AND
JOHN R. DUZON, AND TOMAS PARAL, PERSONAL REPRESENTATIVE OF THE ESTATE OF
ANDY S. PARAL
VS THOMAS L. STALLWORTH, QUEEN BEE TRANSPORT, INC., VENTURE TRANSPORTS, INC., RELIANCE NATIONAL INDEMNITY, CAL-DIVE INTERNATIONAL, INC., AND ABC INSURANCE COMPANY |
| 2001CA1187
(rehearing) |
SALVADOR R.
DUZON, CAROLYN R. DUZON, ON BEHALF OF THE COMMUNITY OF ACQUETS AND GAINS,
INDIVIDUALLY AND ON BEHALF OF THE MINOR CHILDREN, SALVADOR DUZON, JR. AND
JOHN R. DUZON, AND TOMAS PARAL, PERSONAL REPRESENTATIVE OF THE ESTATE OF
ANDY S. PARAL
VS THOMAS L. STALLWORTH, QUEEN BEE TRANSPORT, INC., VENTURE TRANSPORTS, INC., RELIANCE NATIONAL INDEMNITY, CAL-DIVE INTERNATIONAL, INC., AND ABC INSURANCE COMPANY |
| 2001CA2059 |
THE SULTANA CORPORATION D/B/A HANNON JEWELERS VS JEWELERS MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY |
| 2001CA2070 |
MARIE ELAINE D'AMICO RANSOME VS AL JEROME RANSOME |
| 2001CA2070
(rehearing) |
MARIE ELAINE D'AMICO RANSOME VS AL JEROME RANSOME |
| 2001CA2107 |
CATHERINE MCGOWAN HUGHES WIFE OF/AND FRANK A. HUGHES VS JUDY BRANTLEY GOODREAU WIFE OF/AND DARRELL L. GOODREAU |
| 2001CA2164 |
JODY AND LORA BORDELON, INDIVIDUALLY AND ON BEHALF OF THEIR MINOR SON BRANDON VS MEDICAL CENTER OF BATON ROUGE AND ANDREW T. ZARUSKI, M.D. |
| 2001CA2229 |
SHIRLEY AUTIN EUSEA VS ROGER J. BLANCHARD, JR., M.D., ST. PAUL FIRE & MARINE INSURANCE COMPANY, MICHAEL J. MARCELLO, M.D., JOHN HEIDENREICH, M.D., OCHSNER FAMILY CLINIC OF MATTHEWS AND BROADLAWNS MEDICAL CENTER |
| 2001CA2334 |
JOSEPH PAUL WILLARD VS R & B FALCON DRILLING USA, INC. |
| 2001CA2457 |
DONALD DULIN VS LEVIS MITSUBISHI, INC. |
| 2001CA2494 |
STEPHEN RAY BURDETTE VS RON DRUSHELL |
| 2001CA2494
(rehearing) |
STEPHEN RAY BURDETTE VS RON DRUSHELL |
| 2001CW2524 |
CAPITOL HOUSE PRESERVATION COMPANY, L.L.C. VS PERRYMAN CONSULTANTS INCORPORATED; MR. M. RAY PERRYMAN; XYZ INSURANCE COMPANY; AND TUV INSURANCE COMPANY |
| 2001CA2525 |
TWANDA BROWN VS KWOK WONG (MANDARIN SEAFOOD RESTAURANT) AND LOUISIANA RESTAURANT ASSOCIATION SELF INSURER'S FUND |
| 2001CW2528 |
SHEILA B. PITTMAN VS CHRIS ALBERT PITTMAN |
| 2001CA2684 |
JOHN W. PERTUIS, JR. VS ARCHITECTURAL FABRICATIONS, INC. |
| 2001CA2705 |
KATHLEEN DREISEL VS METROPOLITAN PROPERTY & CASUALTY INSURANCE COMPANY |
| 2001CA2750 |
RICKY JAMES PELLEGRIN AND MERRILL CUNNINGHAM PELLEGRIN VS CITY OF THIBODAUX, NOLAN P. ROGER, ETHEL LEGENDRE ROGER, OAK TERRACE MOTEL, INC., AND GSA ASSOCIATES, INC. |
| 2001CA2758 |
PHYLLIS WRIGHT VS WENDY'S (#2501) INTERNATIONAL, INC. |
| 2001CA2819 |
SANDI'S II VS ASSUMPTION PARISH POLICE JURY |
| 2001CA2852 |
ST. MARY ANESTHESIA ASSOCIATES, INC. VS HOSPITAL SERVICE DISTRICT NO. 2 OF THE PARISH OF ST. MARY, STATE OF LOUISIANA D/B/A LAKEWOOD MEDICAL CENTER |
| 2001CA2883 |
STONEGATE HOMEOWNERS CIVIC ASSOCIATION, DAVID BLOUIN, JAMES CHETTA, CONNIE S. CHETTA, HAROLD LEONE, MARTHA B. MILLER, MARY A. O'KEEFE, BARBARA RICHERT AND FRED TOWNSEND VS CITY OF BATON ROUGE/PARISH OF EAST BATON ROUGE, DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC WORKS FOR THE CITY OF BATON ROUGE/PARISH OF EAST BATON ROUGE, CITY PARISH PLANNING COMMISSION FOR THE PARISH OF EAST BATON ROUGE, WOODDALE PLAZA CORPORATION, D. M. "MIKE" FERRELL, ET AL. |
| 2001CA2883
(rehearing) |
STONEGATE HOMEOWNERS CIVIC ASSOCIATION, DAVID BLOUIN, JAMES CHETTA, CONNIE S. CHETTA, HAROLD LEONE, MARTHA B. MILLER, MARY A. O'KEEFE, BARBARA RICHERT AND FRED TOWNSEND VS CITY OF BATON ROUGE/PARISH OF EAST BATON ROUGE, DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC WORKS FOR THE CITY OF BATON ROUGE/PARISH OF EAST BATON ROUGE, CITY PARISH PLANNING COMMISSION FOR THE PARISH OF EAST BATON ROUGE, WOODDALE PLAZA CORPORATION, D. M. "MIKE" FERRELL, ET AL.
|
| 2002CA0022 |
DUSTIN PEPPER VS THOMAS SETH TRIPLET AND ALLSTATE INSURANCE COMPANY |
| 2002CA0022
(rehearing) |
DUSTIN PEPPER VS THOMAS SETH TRIPLET AND ALLSTATE INSURANCE COMPANY |
| 2002CA0024 |
WELMON COMEAUX VS STAR ENTERPRISES/MOTIVA ENTERPRISES |
| 2002CA0025 |
STEVEN GODEAUX VS LEWIS CHAPMAN CONSTRUCTION COMPANY, GUY HOPKINS CONSTRUCTION COMPANY, INC. AND AETNA CASUALTY AND SURETY COMPANY |
| 2002CA0027 |
CARRIE WHITEHEAD AND STATE FARM AUTOMOBILE INSURANCE COMPANY VS AMERICAN COACHWORKS, INC, |
| 2002CA0027
(rehearing 1) |
CARRIE WHITEHEAD AND STATE FARM AUTOMOBILE INSURANCE COMPANY VS AMERICAN COACHWORKS, INC,
|
| 2002CA0027
(rehearing 2) |
CARRIE WHITEHEAD AND STATE FARM AUTOMOBILE INSURANCE COMPANY VS AMERICAN COACHWORKS, INC,
|
| 2002CA0028 |
JODY C. DEAN VS SOUTHMARK CONSTRUCTION AND LOUISIANA WORKERS' COMPENSATION CORPORATION |
| 2002CA0028
(rehearing) |
JODY C. DEAN VS SOUTHMARK CONSTRUCTION AND LOUISIANA WORKERS' COMPENSATION CORPORATION |
| 2002CA0045
|
WINNIFRED LAIRD VS ST. TAMMANY PARISH SAFE HARBOR CONSOLIDATED WITH WINNIFRED LAIRD VS ST. TAMMANY PARISH SAFE HARBOR |
| 2002CA0076
|
PRECIOUS JONES, INDIVIDUALLY AND ON BEHALF OF MELVIN JONES, III AND MELVIN JONES AND TONYA BICKHAM ON BEHALF OF JONATHAN LEWIS (ESTATE OF MELVIN JONES) VS NORTHLAKE DISPOSAL SERVICES CONSOLIDATED WITH TONYA BICKHAM ON BEHALF OF JONATHAN LEWIS (ESTATE OF MELVIN JONES), ET AL VS NORTHLAKE DISPOSAL SERVICES
|
| 2002CA0082 |
CARL J. FONTENOT ON BEHALF OF HIS MINOR CHILD, MICHAEL C. FONTENOT VS CATHERINE A. CHOPPIN, TRUSTEE, AND THE MICHAEL C. FONTENOT TRUST |
| 2002CA0086 |
ERIC LAPEYROUSE, SR./MV MISS GEORGIANA VS JOE WILLIAMS BARBAREE/MV RISKY BUSINESS |
| 2002CA0103 |
SHEILA MORALES SMITH VS PHILLIP MORRIS, U.S.A. AND HARTFORD INSURANCE COMPANY |
| 2002CA0126 |
LYNN MALLORY VS PINEAPPLE MANAGEMENT SERVICES, INC. |
| 2002CA0139 |
BRENDA PIERCE, INDIVIDUALLY AND APPEARING IN HER CAPACITY AS THE PROVISIONAL TUTRIX OF THE MINOR SON, RUSSELL H. HAYDEN; DAVID VERBERNE, SR., INDIVIDUALLY AND ON BEHALF OF HIS MINOR SON, ROBERT M. VERBERNE, ET AL. VS TANGIPAHOA PARISH SCHOOL BOARD, UNITED NATIONAL INSURANCE COMPANY, ORA FINN, HARRY HOSE, SR. AND MARY ANN HOSE, PARENTS OF HARRY HOSE; VICK CUTI AND DELORES CALLIHAN, GUARDIAN AND MOTHER, RESPECTIVELY, OF THE MINOR CHILD, KALLY CALLIHAN, JOHN HART, ET AL. |
| 2002CA0153 |
BARBARA DUPRE & FERRELL DUPRE VS JOHN FLOYD, M.D. VICTOR TEDESCO, M.D., CHARLES LEDOUX, M.D. AND TERREBONNE GENERAL MEDICAL CENTER |
| 2002CA0166 |
CITY OF BATON ROUGE/PARISH OF EAST BATON ROUGE VS EVEST ANTONIO BROUSSARD, EVEST ANTONIO BROUSSARD, II AND FRANCES BROUSSARD HOLLIDAY |
| 2002CA0166
(rehearing) |
CITY OF BATON ROUGE/PARISH OF EAST BATON ROUGE VS EVEST ANTONIO BROUSSARD, EVEST ANTONIO BROUSSARD, II AND FRANCES BROUSSARD HOLLIDAY |
| 2002CA0169 |
SHARON DESOTO VS NIDAL BALBEISI, USAGENCIES CASUALTY INSURANCE COMPANY AND STATE FARM MUTUAL AUTOMOBILE INSURANCE COMPANY |
| 2002CA0169
(rehearing) |
SHARON DESOTO VS NIDAL
BALBEISI, USAGENCIES CASUALTY INSURANCE COMPANY AND STATE FARM MUTUAL AUTOMOBILE INSURANCE COMPANY |
| 2002CA0195
|
J. CARMEN SUAREZ VS ANDERSON INDUSTRIAL SCAFFOLDING CONSOLIDATED WITH J. CARMEN SUAREZ VS ANDERSON INDUSTRIAL SCAFFOLDING
|
| 2002CA0197 |
RICHARD SEAL AND DREE SEAL VS RICHARD DUNHAM AND ANNETTE DUNHAM |
| 2002CA0205 |
ANN MURPHY VS DENISE VINET AND HER INSURER, GILSBAR, INC. |
| 2002CA0205
(rehearing) |
ANN MURPHY VS DENISE VINET AND HER INSURER,
GILSBAR, INC. |
| 2002CA0208 |
TAMMY M. CAYE VS SLIDELL TRAVEL CENTER |
| 2002CA0209 |
CHERYL ALLEN COLLINS VS PHIL D. RANDALL, EMPIRE FIRE AND MARINE INSURANCE COMPANY, ABC INSURANCE COMPANY AND ENTERPRISE LEASING COMPANY OF NEW ORLEANS |
| 2002CA0222 |
SUSAN MCKNEELY FOWLER VS CLAUDE ED FOWLER |
| 2002CA0222
(rehearing) |
SUSAN MCKNEELY FOWLER VS CLAUDE ED FOWLER |
| 2002CA0243
|
LANCE A. TARANTO VS STRANCO CONSOLIDATED WITH LANCE A. TARANTO VS STRANCO, INC.
|
| 2002CA0254 |
RODNEY REVERE VS RODNEY STRAIN, SHERIFF ST.TAMMANY PARISH AND INDIVIDUALLY |
| 2002CA0292 |
LISA FRIEDLEY VS ALEXANDER ELECTRICAL, INC. AND CNA INSURANCE COMPANIES |
| 2002CA0294 |
ERNEST GRIFFIN AND LUCY GRIFFIN VS WICKES LUMBER COMPANY AND/OR WICKES INC. (DELAWARE) AND ABC INSURANCE COMPANY, ERNEST GROSS AND WESTAFF, INC. (F/K/A WESTERN TEMPORARY SERVICES) |
| 2002CA0294
(rehearing) |
ERNEST GRIFFIN AND LUCY GRIFFIN VS WICKES LUMBER COMPANY AND/OR WICKES INC. (DELAWARE) AND ABC INSURANCE COMPANY, ERNEST GROSS AND
WESTAFF, INC. (F/K/A WESTERN TEMPORARY SERVICES) |
| 2002CA0310 |
DEBRA CRITSER VS DILLARD'S DEPARTMENT STORE, INC. |
| 2002CA0358 |
TOMMY MORRISON VS THE CITY OF BATON ROUGE (BATON ROUGE POLICE DEPARTMENT) AND PAT ENGLADE, CHIEF OF POLICE |
| 2002CA0603 |
CARL D. WRIGHT VS JANET WAGUESPACK |
| 2002CA0771 |
JOSEPH A. WHITE, III, JOHN L. MONSON AND ANTHONY J. CASHIOLA, SR. VS GENERAL MOTORS CORPORATION, BROCKHOEFT'S CHEVROLET, INC. AND HANKS PONTIAC-GMC BUICK, INC. |
| 2002CA0771
(rehearing) |
JOSEPH A. WHITE, III, JOHN L. MONSON AND ANTHONY J. CASHIOLA, SR. VS GENERAL MOTORS CORPORATION, BROCKHOEFT'S CHEVROLET, INC. AND HANKS PONTIAC-GMC BUICK, INC. |
| 2002CA0830 |
SHIRLEY AVANTS AND JIM W. MILEY VS JOHN NEELY KENNEDY, SECRETARY, DEPARTMENT OF REVENUE AND TAXATION, STATE OF LOUISIANA AND ELMER LITCHFIELD, SHERIFF OF EAST BATON ROUGE PARISH |
| 2002KA0993 |
STATE OF LOUISIANA VS DAVID M. KIRSCH |
| 2002KJ1867 |
STATE OF LOUISIANA IN THE INTEREST OF L.A.H.
|