June2000

PUBLISHED OPINIONS

June 2000

Disclaimer: Formatting and page numbers of the electronic version of First Circuit opinions may not exactly match the original hard copy.

To download a file, right click on the link (case number) and select "Save Target As" for Internet Explorer or "Save Link As" for Netscape Navigator.

00CA0101	DAVID L. DAVIES VS HARD STALDER, C. M. LENSING AND MARIANA LEGER
99CA1384	JOHN HERMAN LEE TAYLOR VS STATE OF LOUISIANA THROUGH THE DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION AND DEVELOPMENT
99CA2106	MELISSA BRAUD VS FIRST NATIONAL BANK OF GONZALES ,PARRO, J., dissenting in part.
99CA2106	MELISSA BRAUD VS FIRST NATIONAL BANK OF GONZALES, AFFIRMED IN PART, REVERSED IN PART, VACATED IN PART AND REMANDED.
99CA2106	MELISSA BRAUD VS FIRST NATIONAL BANK OF GONZALES, KLINE, J. Pro Tempore, Concurs in Part and Dissents in Part
98A2160R	MICHAEL SALLINGER VS GLENN ROBICHAUX d/b/a ROBICHAUX QUICK STOP and ESSEX INSURANCE COMPANY
98A2472	WALL V. MCKNEELY VS MARGARET THOMPSON MCKNEELY
99CA0069	DR. ALLEN J. ELLENDER, JR., ET AL. VS GOLDKING PRODUCTION COMPANY AND DENOVO OIL & GAS COMPANY
99CA0073	EXXON PIPELINE COMPANY VS GEORGE HILL, INDIVIDUALLY AND AS TRUSTEE OF THE MRS. ELIZABETH J. HILL TRUST FOR THE CHILDREN OF JOHN HILL, JR., ET AL AFFIRMED IN PART, REVERSED IN PART AND RENDERED
99CA0073	EXXON PIPELINE COMPANY VS GEORGE HILL, INDIVIDUALLY AND AS TRUSTEE OF THE MRS. ELIZABETH J. HILL TRUST FOR THE CHILDREN OF JOHN HILL, JR., ET AL FITZSIMMONS, Judge, dissenting, with reasons
99CA0073	EXXON PIPELINE COMPANY VS GEORGE HILL, INDIVIDUALLY AND AS TRUSTEE OF THE MRS. ELIZABETH J. HILL TRUST FOR THE CHILDREN OF JOHN HILL, JR., ET AL SHORTESS, C.J., CONCURRING
99CA0073	EXXON PIPELINE COMPANY VS GEORGE HILL, INDIVIDUALLY AND AS TRUSTEE OF THE MRS. ELIZABETH J. HILL TRUST FOR THE CHILDREN OF JOHN HILL, JR., ET AL PARRO, J., dissenting
99A0354	L & A CONTRACTING COMPANY, INC. VS RAM INDUSTRIAL COATINGS, INC. AND TRANSAMERICA PREMIER INSURANCE COMPANY
99A0670	LIGA/MORTEM RISK MANAGEMENT VS J. M. FRANKS
99CA0698 99CA0699	SYLVIA M. DICKENS, GIRLIE SIMS WARREN AND GENNIE L. WARREN VS COMMERCIAL UNION INSURANCE COMPANY, ORDIA BYRD JOHNSON, CITY OF BATON ROUGE, PARISH OF EAST BATON ROUGE, THROUGH EAST BATON ROUGE HOUSING AUTHORITY AND WILLIE COLLINS (Consolidated With) WILLIE COLLINS, MELVIN DIXON, ELICE PARKER, SR., AND PATSY PITTMAN VS ORDIA BYRD JOHNSON, EAST BATON ROUGE PARISH HOUSING AUTHORITY, AND COMMERCIAL UNION INSURANCE COMPANY
99CA0709	COMM-CARE CORPORATION VS LOUISIANA TAX COMMISSION, ELMER LITCHFIELD, IN THIS CAPACITYAS SHERIFF AND EX-OFFICIO TAX COLLECTOR OF THE PARISH OF EAST BATON ROUGE; RONNIE BOOK, IN HIS CAPACITY AS SHERIFF AND EX-OFFICIO TAX COLLECTOR OF THE PARISH OF CATAHOULA; WILLIE WAYNE HOUCK, IN HIS CAPACITY AS SHERIFF AND EX-OFFICIO TAX COLLECTOR OF THE PARISH OF LINCOLN; WILLIAM EARL HILTON, IN HIS CAPACITY AS SHERIFF AND EX-OFFICIO TAX COLLECTOR OF THE PARISH OF RAPIDES; FRANK A HOWARD, IN HIS CAPACITY AS SHERIFF AND EX-OFFICIO TAX COLLECTOR OF THE PARISH OF VERNON; JEFFREY F. WILEY, IN HIS CAPACITY AS SHERIFF AND EX-OFFICIO TAX COLLECTOR OF THE PARISH OF ASCENSION; WILLIAM BELT, IN HIS CAPACITY AS SHERIFF AND EX-OFFICIO TAX COLLECTOR OF THE PARISH OF AVOYELLES; M. BOLIVAR BISHOP, IN HIS CAPACITY AS SHERIFF AND EX-OFFICIO TAX COLLECTOR OF THE PARISH OF BEAUREGARD; CHARLES L. COOK, IN HIS CAPACITY AS SHERIFF AND EX-OFFICIO TAX COLLECTOR OF THE PARISH OF OUACHITA; CYNTHIA DAUZAT, IN HER CAPACITY AS EX-OFFICIO TAX COLLECTOR OF THE CITY OF BUNKIE; DEBORAH SAVAGE, IN HER CAPACITY AS EX-OFFICIO TAX COLLECTOR OF THE CITY OF JONESVILLE; CHARLES OTIS, IN HIS CAPACITY AS EX-OFFICIO TAX COLLECTOR OF THE CITY OF DONALDSONVILLE; BENNY CHELETTE, IN HIS CAPACITY AS EX-OFFICIO TAX COLLECTOR OF THE CITY OF WEST MONROE; THE PARISH OF ASCENSION; THE PARISH OF AVOYELLES; THE PARISH OF BEAUREGARD; THE PARISH OF CATAHOULA; THE PARISH OF EAST BATON ROUGE; THE PARISH OF LINCOLN; THE PARISH OF OUACHITA; THE PARISH OF RAPIDES; THE PARISH OF VERNON; THE CITY OF BUNKIE; THE CITY OF DONALDSONVILLE; THE CITY OF JONESVILLE; THE CITY OF WEST MONROE; GERALD MCCRORY, JR. IN HIS CAPACITY AS ASSESSOR FOR THE PARISH OF ASCENSION; LEE F. THEVENOTE IN HIS CAPACITY AS ASSESSOR FOR THE PARISH OF AVOYELLES; BOBBY CUDD IN HIS CAPACITY ASSESSOR FOR THE PARISH OF BEAUREGARD; CARMON WALKER IN HIS CAPACITY AS ASSESSOR FOR THE PARISH OF CATAHOULA; FRANK GRANGER, III IN HIS CAPACITY AS ASSESSOR FOR THE PARISH OF EAST BATON ROUGE; JEWETTE FARLEY IN HIS CAPACITY AS ASSESSOR FOR THE PARISH OF LINCOLN; RICH BAILEY IN HIS CAPACITY AS ASSESSOR FOR THE PARISH OF OUACHITA; RALPH GILL IN HIS CAPACITY AS ASSESSOR FOR THE PARISH OF RAPIDES; EUGENE CAVANAUGH IN HIS CAPACITY AS ASSESSOR FOR THE PARISH OF VERNON
99CA0766	WADE TERREBONNE, INDIVIDUALLY AND AS NATURAL TUTOR OF THE MINOR, DEREK JAMES TERREBONNE AND RACHEL TERREBONNE VS JOHN C. FLOYD, M.D.
99CA0824	JERRY M. GRAVOIS, INDIVIDUALLY AND ON BEHALF OF THE MINOR CHELSEY LYNN GRAVOIS, AND MARY CROCHET GRAVOIS VS DELTA AIRLINES, INC. AND BATON ROUGE METROPOLITAN AIRPORT
99CA0904 99CA0905	INSURANCE COMPANY OF NORTH AMERICA VS GAYLORD CONTAINER CORPORATION and XYZ INSURANCE COMPANY CONSOLIDATED WITH JOHNNY LABAUVE VS GAYLORD CONTAINER CORPORATION and XYZ INSURANCE COMPANY
99CA0924	TENET HEALTHSYSTEMS HOSPITALS, INC. d/b/a NORTHSHORE REGIONAL MEDICAL CENTER VS PARISH OF ST. TAMMANY; ST. TAMMANY PARISH SCHOOL BOARD; ST. TAMMANY PARISH POLICE JURY; THE COLLECTOR OF SALES AND USE TAXES FOR THE PARISH OF ST. TAMMANY; THE TREASURER AND/OR SUPERINTENDENT OF ST. TAMMANY PARISH POLICE JURY; ST. TAMMANY PARISH LAW ENFORCEMENT DISTRICT
99CA0935	NACE J. MACALUSO VS RON S. MACALUSO, RICHARD C. MACALUSO, AND DEBBI MACALUSO PEARE
99CA1036	WADE TERREBONNE, INDIVIDUALLY AND AS NATURAL TUTOR OF THE MINOR, DEREK JAMES TERREBONNE AND RACHEL TERREBONNE VS JOHN C. FLOYD, M.D.
99CA1052	NETTIE JEAN MILLICAN VS ISAAC PONDS, DESSELLE FUNERAL HOME AND COMMERCIAL UNION INSURANCE COMPANY
99CA1070 99CA1071	ANGELA H. BUTZ AND RUSSELL BUTZ VS JAMES P. LYNCH, THE ESTATE OF PATRICK O. LYNCH, STATE FARM MUTUAL AUTOMOBILE INSURANCE CO., AND STATE FARM FIRE AND CASUALTY COMPANY CONSOLIDATED WITH: FRANCIS R. WHITE, III, ON BEHALF OF HIS SON, FRANCIS RANDALL WHITE, IV VS STATE FARM AUTOMOBILE MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY, STATE FARM FIRE AND CASUALTY CO., JAMES P. LYNCH, AND THE ESTATE OF PATRICK O. LYNCH
99CA1089	TRACEY HOFFPAUIR, VICKI HOFFPAUIR AND VICTIMS AND CITIZENS AGAINST CRIME VS STATE OF LOUISIANA, DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY AND CORRECTIONS, THE LOUISIANA STATE BOARD OF PARDONS, THE LOUISIANA STATE PAROLE BOARD, CYNTHIA FAYARD, LYNISE KENNEDY, NETTIE MILLICAN, JOHN GRASSO AND LARRY CLARK
99CA1099	SHELDON STRASNER, ET AL. VS STATE OF LOUISIANA, ET AL.
99CA1149	MARK S. WORTHEN AND HELEN L. WORTHEN VS CHARLES DELONG, JUNALISE DELONG, AND CITY/PARISH OF EAST BATON ROUGE
99CA1150	MICHAEL O’NEAL STOKES VS JACK STRAIN, SHERIFF; CAPT. GREGORY LONGINO; SGT. MAGALETTI; DY. EVA (AVA) ANDREWS; JIM HAMLER; MEDICAL AT JAIL
99CA1166	THOMAS BARRY REILY VS JOSEPH J. FREY, CREDIT GENERAL INSURANCE COMPANY and HARTFORD INSURANCE COMPANY
99CA1168	KEVIN P. BOUDREAUX VS LOUISIANA CASINO CRUISES, INC., d/b/a CASINO ROUGE AND JOHN CAUSEY
99CA1200	BATON ROUGE COMPUTER SALES, INC. D/B/A COMPUTERLAND VS LAURIE MILLER-CONRAD
99CA1201	EDWIN GILES VS BURL CAIN, ET AL
99CA1221	JEANNETTE CHAMPAGNE COFFEY VS JERALD P. BLOCK, KEITH J. LABAT AND COREGIS INSURANCE COMPANY
99CA1292	MARY GRAY VS HOLIDAY INNS, INC., d/b/a HOLIDAY INN
99CA1325	JAMES C. DIXON VS ELIZABETH J. DIXON
99CA1328	CARMEN THERESA FRUGE GERALD VS JEFFERSON DONALD GERALD
99CA1377	DAMON DEVILLE VS SOUTH CENTRAL INDUSTRIES, INC. AND LOUISIANA HEALTH SERVICE & INDEMNITY CO. d/b/a BLUE CROSS AND BLUE SHIELD OF LOUISIANA
99CA1379	ANTOINETTE PROCTOR BAECHLE VS KEITH ANDRE BAECHLE
99CA1381	TIM WILKINSON VS AIR LOGISTICS AND J. RAY MCDERMOTT, INC., MARINE FABRICATION AND SHIPYARD OPERATIONS
99CA1389 99CA1390 99CA1391 99CA1392 99CA1393 99CA1394 99CA1395 99CA1396	SANDRA GORBATY VS DEPARTMENT OF STATE CIVIL SERVICE AND DHH-OFFICE OF MENTAL HEALTH consolidated with STEVE MCBEE VS DEPARTMENT OF STATE CIVIL SERVICE AND DHH-OFFICE OF MENTAL HEALTH consolidated with JOHN T. HARRISON, JR. VS DEPARTMENT OF STATE CIVIL SERVICE AND DHH-OFFICE OF MENTAL HEALTH consolidated with JACQUES RODLEY GALTIER VS DEPARTMENT OF STATE CIVIL SERVICE AND DHH-OFFICE OF MENTAL HEALTH consolidated with REBECCA HART VS DEPARTMENT OF STATE CIVIL SERVICE AND DHH-OFFICE OF MENTAL HEALTH consolidated with CATHERINE J. KIDD VS DEPARTMENT OF STATE CIVIL SERVICE AND DHH-OFFICE OF MENTAL HEALTH consolidated with SARAH MORRIS VS DEPARTMENT OF STATE CIVIL SERVICE AND DHH-OFFICE OF MENTAL HEALTH consolidated with LENA CROSS VS DEPARTMENT OF STATE CIVIL SERVICE AND DHH-OFFICE OF MENTAL HEALTH
99CA1430	LOLA GREEN VS SOUTHERN UNITED FIRE INSURANCE COMPANY, SAFEWAY INSURANCE COMPANY, RITA JONES AND BARRON MAGEE
99CA1437	EXXON PIPELINE CO. VS V. PRICE LEBLANC, SHIRLEY WOLF LEBLANC AND SIMON CORPORATION OF LOUISIANA (LeBlanc)
99CA1437	EXXON PIPELINE CO. VS V. PRICE LEBLANC, SHIRLEY WOLF LEBLANC AND SIMON CORPORATION OF LOUISIANA (Fitzsimmons)
99CA1437	EXXON PIPELINE CO. VS V. PRICE LEBLANC, SHIRLEY WOLF LEBLANC AND SIMON CORPORATION OF LOUISIANA (Shortess)
99CA1437	XXON PIPELINE CO. VS V. PRICE LEBLANC, SHIRLEY WOLF LEBLANC AND SIMON CORPORATION OF LOUISIANA (Parro)
99CA1449 99CW1278	ANNE GUZZARDO-KNIGHT, LEONARD KNIGHT & N. GUZZARDO COMPANY, INC. D/B/A LOUISIANA STEELWORKS VS CENTRAL PROGRESSIVE BANK, ADAMS AND REESE, A REGISTERED LIMITED LIABILITY PARTNERSHIP & ABC INSURANCE COMPANY
99CA1453	NATIONAL AUTOMOTIVE INSURANCE COMPANY AND MICHAEL DOUCET VS ODOM'S TIRE & CAR CARE CENTER, INC. AND THE HANOVER INSURANCE COMPANY
99CA1534	DOROTHY SIMMONS AND MICHELLE BOUTTE VS BRIAN J. BRAQUET, CONQUES TRUCKING COMPANY AND CLARENDON NATIONAL INSURANCE COMPANY
99CA1569	MARY BILLIOT AND EUGENE BILLIOT VS K-MART CORPORATION
99CA1571	LAURA M. VICTORIAN, ALBERT VICTORIAN, ERNEST J. VICTORIAN, JAMES C. VICTORIAN, LOIS A. VICTORIAN and CHARLES A. VICTORIAN, INDIVIDUALLY AND ON BEHALF OF THE ESTATE OF GERALDINE VICTORIAN VS AMERICAN DEPOSIT INSURANCE COMPANY, ESTEBAN RODRIGUEZ and JAMES F. KENT
99CA1573	IN THE MATTER OF THE SUCCESSION OF DONALD MAURICE BARTHEL
99CA1582	CITY OF DONALDSONVILLE, NOLAN GUILLOT d/b/a FIRST AND LAST CHANCE and ERIC WEIL d/b/a CAFĖ LAFOURCHE VS STATE OF LOUISIANA, LOUISIANA GAMBLING CONTROL BOARD and LOUISIANA STATE POLICE
99CA1587	ROBERT MCDOWELL VS SUSAN TAYLOR, MAJOR MILLS, COL. ROBINSON, DR. BELICK
99CA1632	CALVIN MATTHEWS VS VIP INTERNATIONAL, INC. AND LOUISIANA WORKERS’ COMPENSATION CORPORATION
99CA2230	CITY OF BATON ROUGE/PARISH OF EAST BATON ROUGE VS JOHNCA PROPERTIES, L.L.C.
99CA2230	CITY OF BATON ROUGE/PARISH OF EAST BATON ROUGE VS JOHNCA PROPERTIES, L.L.C. (Pettigrew)
99CA 2230	CITY OF BATON ROUGE/PARISH OF EAST BATON ROUGE VS JOHNCA PROPERTIES, L.L.C. (Parro)
99CA2230	CITY OF BATON ROUGE/PARISH OF EAST BATON ROUGE VS JOHNCA PROPERTIES, L.L.C. (Shortess)
99CA2952	LOUISIANA MUNICIPAL ASSOCIATION VS STATE OF LOUISIANA, THROUGH MURPHY J. FOSTER, GOVERNOR OF LOUISIANA, AND RICHARD P. IEYOUB, ATTORNEY GENERAL OF LOUISIANA
99CW1525R	IN RE: ROBERT L. BICKHAM, ET AL. VS METROPOLITAN LIFE INSURANCE CO., ET AL.
99KA1524	STATE OF LOUISIANA VS LEE LUCAS
99KA1945	STATE OF LOUISIANA VS JERMAINE HENDERSON
99KA1973	STATE OF LOUISIANA VS GERALD HAYNES

EXXON PIPELINE COMPANY VS GEORGE HILL, INDIVIDUALLY AND AS TRUSTEE OF THE MRS. ELIZABETH J. HILL TRUST FOR THE CHILDREN OF JOHN HILL, JR., ET AL

L & A CONTRACTING COMPANY, INC. VS RAM INDUSTRIAL COATINGS, INC. AND TRANSAMERICA PREMIER INSURANCE COMPANY